Americans with Disabilities Act Archives

Americans with Disabilities Act

Why the ADA Doesn’t Address Bed Height

Candy B. Harrington accessible, ADA, Americans with Disabilities Act, bed height, Department of Justice, DOJ, hotels, regulations April 8, 2024

The American’s with Disabilities Act (ADA) covers a lot of issues in public accommodations; however the ADA doesn’t address bed height. This presents numerous problems for wheelchair-users and slow walkers who need to check into a hotel or motel.

Unfortunately there’s no real agreement on what an “accessible bed” should be. Most wheelchair-users prefer lower beds, while slow walkers with hip or knee issues need higher beds. And then there are wheelchair-users who use portable hoyer lifts who need open-frame beds, as opposed to the standard platforms. And those are just a few of the reasons why the ADA doesn’t address bed height.

So why is there’s no consensus on this matter? Well first and foremost, disabilities are diverse, and you just can’t put one group’s needs over the other. To be honest the same problem was encountered when the toilet height regulations for the ADA were crafted. The lower height was ultimately accepted because there was a cheap and easy fix for folks that needed higher toilets — toilet risers. Unfortunately there’s no cheap and easy fix for beds.

A Little History

The Department of Justice (DOJ) once considered addressing the bed height issue. Back on July 26, 2010 they issued an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPR), that asked for public input on the accessibility of equipment and removable furniture, such as beds. And boy did they get an earful, as disability organizations and advocates weighed in from across the country. Granted the DOJ never said they were going to move forward and issue regulations, however due to the input received, it was assumed that some preliminary rules would at least be forthcoming.

Sadly that wasn’t the case. In a move that surprised a number of disability advocates, the DOJ instead issued a withdrawal of the ANPR and published that decision in the December 26, 2017 issue of the Federal Register.

So what does this mean? Basically it means that the rulemaking process has ended and the DOJ is not going to consider new rules for equipment and removable furniture. According to the DOJ, they are “reevaluating” whether a regulation like this is necessary. Given that places of public accommodation must ensure access to people with different disabilities, the feeling seems to be that perhaps exact specifications aren’t necessary, because beds of different heights work for different disabilities.

What’s a Traveler to Do?

Since the ADA doesn’t address bed height, travelers need to be more proactive when making lodging reservations. Never assume a bed will be a specific height. Always ask. And don’t call the 800 number for the property — call the direct number and speak to someone on site.

And if the person at the front desk can’t help you, ask to speak to someone in housekeeping. These are the folks that are in and out these rooms every day. If they don’t know the specific height, then ask if they can go and measure the bed.

If the bed is too high for you to use, then ask if it can be lowered by removing the frame. And if that’s not possible, ask if you can have a roll-away bed delivered to the room. Those beds are usually lower.

Unfortunately the trend is for higher beds these days, as many properties feel that this helps cut down on injuries to housekeeping workers. That said, even though the ADA doesn’t address bed height, you can still usually find a bed that will work for you with a little legwork. In the end, the best rule of thumb is to plan ahead to avoid unwanted surprises.

Ask The Expert

How Can I Train My Dog to be a Service Animal?

Candy B. Harrington ACAA, ADA, Air Carrier Access Act, Americans with Disabilities Act, Center for Independent Living, certification, service animal, train February 17, 2024

I use a manual wheelchair and I’d like to train my dog to be a service animal so I can travel with him. There are so many places that offer training, certification and registration online, and I really have no idea of where to go. Can you recommend some certified trainers or schools, and also direct me to the official place to register my dog as a service animal?

Service Animal Training Resources

Service dogs help people in wheelchairs do a number of things. They can pick up things, open and close automatic doors, carry items, turn on lights and even retrieve a wheelchair that’s out of reach. That said, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), no official training, certification or registration is required for a dog to be considered a service animal. The only requirement is that the animal must perform a task or tasks to assist a person with a disability.

You can certainly self-train your dog to perform tasks to assist you — at home and when you travel. A good way to find an experienced trainer to work with you is to contact your local Center for Independent Living (CIL) and ask them for referrals to trainers that have worked with their clients. CILs are located throughout the US and they offer excellent disability-related resources. Here’s a directory to find one near you. ilru.org/projects/cil-net/cil-center-and-association-directory

There are also a number of reputable organizations that train service dogs and then pair them with folks who need them. These organizations usually begin with puppies and the training takes almost two years. After graduation each dog is paired with a person with a disability, and the team then undergoes additional training at the organization’s facility. Financial aid is usually available, and some service dog organizations operate as non-profits and provide the animals to qualified applicants at no charge. The wait for these animals can be several years; however since you want to train your own dog, these organizations aren’t a viable option for you.

Red Flags!

Finally, there are a number of websites that offer service dog certification, registration and equipment. In most cases you should steer clear of these sites, which are more commonly known as card mills. For a fee they will give you a card that says your dog is a service animal, add them to their registry and even send them a vest or a harness. Although there’s nothing technically illegal about this, it’s an unnecessary expense because in most cases you don’t need any official certification, registration or even a card for your dog to be classified as a service animal. Some of these websites also offer to certify dogs as emotional support animals, which are not recognized under the ADA or the Air Carrier Access Act (which governs accessible air travel).

It should also be noted that under the ADA, service animals are not required to wear tags, vests or harnesses that identify them as service animals. All that’s needed is the verbal assurance that the animal preforms tasks for an individual with a disability. Finally, be especially skeptical of any site that claims they are the “official service animal registry”, because according to the ADA there is no such thing.

I’m sure you’ll do a good job training your dog, and in the end you’ll have a great helper.